Chicken Bank

Why responsibility is not ownership

Who a purchase was for is not a percentage of the household's cash.

A shared purchase asks two questions, and they have different answers.

Who paid is a wallet. The book's wallet moved, or a person paid from money the book cannot see. That event happens once. Splitting it into a second expense would make the dinner cost twice.

Who it was for is a responsibility. Four people can share a dinner equally, or one person can take the whole of it, without any of them owning a quarter of the household's bank account. The cash is still the book's cash. The debt on a card is still the book's debt. Whose spending adds up the purchases people were assigned, and leaves the unassigned ones visible. It does not divide net position by the number of members.

That is why paying someone back is not a new expense. The spending was the dinner. The payback moves cash and reduces what the book owes them. If the payback were spending, the budget would count the dinner twice, once when you ate and once when you settled.

It is also why a contribution is not income. Money a member agreed to put in was already theirs, moving into the household wallet. Calling it income would make the household look as if it had earned the rent money.

The app will not invent the other model. If you need "this savings account is half mine," that is a different agreement from a split, and it is not calculated by counting the members.

See People and Split a shared expense.

Last updated on